Brooklyn's Jane Doe: The Mishandling of a Sexual Assault Investigation
By (Author) S. A. Mathers
Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Bloomsbury Academic
2nd October 2025
United Kingdom
General
Non Fiction
Violent crimes
Forensic science
Hardback
192
Width 140mm, Height 216mm
I have had the misfortune of being raped twiceonce in the park and again in the media, wrote Jane Doe, the victim of an infamous stranger rape in Brooklyn, New York. Two decades later, detective S. A. Mathers reopened Doe's case to bring her justice.
In April 1994, the horrific details of Jane Does assault were widely covered by New York City newspapers following misleading information from NYPD officials to Pulitzer Prize-winning crime reporter Mike McAlary. Convinced that Doe, a queer woman of color, was fabricating her account for political amplification, McAlary launched a journalistic smear campaign against her. Permanent harm was done to Jane Doe, who was ridiculed and gaslighted publicly, and thus to all survivors who faced the silencing specter of being disbelieved. Twenty-three years later, as the lead investigator on the case, retired detective S. A. Mathers helped Doe achieve the apology and closure she had long desired when her case was finally allowed to be reopened and reinvestigated. Brooklyns Jane Doe tells her story and highlights the struggle for justice that so many survivors face.
S. A. Mathers is a retired First Grade Detective, and she spent fourteen of her twenty-year career with the NYPD investigating some of New York Citys most violent and high profile sexual assault cases. Mathers holds a Master of Science in Criminal Justice and is a former adjunct professor at Farmingdale State College and John Jay College of Criminal Justice. Sarah has been recognized by New York City Counsel and by Detective Endowment Association for her work on sexual assault cases. She was also a team detective for the Harvey Weinstein investigation.